Did single-family homes in St. Augustine and northern St. Johns County sell faster in October 2026 than a year earlier?
Yes. Median reported market time fell in both areas, and median closing prices were higher, even though the number of sales followed different paths. For homeowners considering a sale or a second attempt after an unsuccessful listing, the important detail is that some newly built homes were entered into the MLS at closing, making the headline selling-time figures look faster than the experience of other listings.
What stands out
In St. Augustine (32080, 32084, 32092 and 32095), October closed sales were virtually unchanged: 192 in 2026 versus 193 in 2025. The median sold price rose to $540,000 from $510,000, while median cumulative days on market (CDOM) fell to 54 from 70.
In northern St. Johns County (32259 and 32081), closings declined to 137 from 159, while the median price rose to $620,185 from $599,900. Median CDOM fell to 39 from 78.
Key Takeaway: October 2026 buyers paid a higher median price in both of these single-family home markets, but sellers should not assume every existing home will sell in the headline number of days. New-construction closings entered at completion influence the market-time figures.
October market snapshot
| Metric | St. Augustine 2026 | St. Augustine 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Closed sales | 192 | 193 | −0.5% |
| Median sold price | $540,000 | $510,000 | +5.9% |
| Average sold price | $642,912 | $625,104 | +2.8% |
| Median CDOM | 54 days | 70 days | −16 days |
| Median sold $/sq. ft. | $232.95 | $235.99 | −1.3% |
| Average sale-to-final-list price | 97.7% | 97.5% | +0.2 percentage points |
| Closed dollar volume | $123,439,161 | $120,645,139 | +2.3% |
| Metric | Northern St. Johns 2026 | Northern St. Johns 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Closed sales | 137 | 159 | −13.8% |
| Median sold price | $620,185 | $599,900 | +3.4% |
| Average sold price | $701,832 | $655,796 | +7.0% |
| Median CDOM | 39 days | 78 days | −39 days |
| Median sold $/sq. ft. | $260.89 | $247.59 | +5.4% |
| Average sale-to-final-list price | 98.7% | 97.5% | +1.2 percentage points |
| Closed dollar volume | $96,151,052 | $104,271,588 | −7.8% |
Active listings, pending sales and months of supply: N/A in the supplied closing records. The separate countywide dashboard is not a ZIP-specific inventory measure.
Are St. Augustine single-family home prices up?
Direct Answer: In St. Augustine ZIP codes 32080, 32084, 32092 and 32095, the October 2026 median sold price was $540,000, compared with $510,000 in October 2025.
What it means: The median rose 5.9%, but that does not mean every home appreciated by 5.9%. The homes that sold in each month may differ in size, location, age and condition.
October sales were almost unchanged at 192 versus 193. For a homeowner considering a sale, that is a reason to compare with the most relevant nearby homes rather than applying a broad percentage to an asking price.
Did northern St. Johns County homes sell faster?
Direct Answer: In ZIP codes 32259 and 32081, median reported CDOM dropped from 78 days in October 2025 to 39 days in October 2026 for all single-family closings.
What it means: Some of that improvement comes from new-construction homes entered into the MLS at closing. Excluding the identified 0–1-day new-construction entries, median CDOM was 57 days versus 87 days. That is still shorter, but it is a more useful comparison for many owners preparing to relist.
The 0–1-day group included 23 closings in October 2026 versus 10 in October 2025. These are a subset of new-construction closings, not a complete count of every newly built home.
How much did new-construction closings affect the two markets?
Direct Answer: The identified 0–1-day new-construction entries accounted for 24 of 192 October 2026 St. Augustine sales and 23 of 137 northern St. Johns County sales.
What it means: These closing entries are real sales, but their reported marketing time is not necessarily comparable with a resale that was actively offered to buyers for weeks.
| Market and group | Oct. 2025 sales | Oct. 2026 sales | Median price 2025 → 2026 | Median CDOM 2025 → 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| St. Augustine: all closings | 193 | 192 | $510,000 → $540,000 | 70 → 54 |
| St. Augustine: excluding identified 0–1-day entries | 179 | 168 | $505,000 → $539,999.50 | 80 → 65.5 |
| St. Augustine: identified new-construction entries | 14 | 24 | $775,000 → $618,363 | 0 → 0 |
| Northern St. Johns: all closings | 159 | 137 | $599,900 → $620,185 | 78 → 39 |
| Northern St. Johns: excluding identified 0–1-day entries | 149 | 114 | $585,990 → $629,000 | 87 → 57 |
| Northern St. Johns: identified new-construction entries | 10 | 23 | $742,883.50 → $620,185 | 0 → 1 |
The group excluding 0–1-day entries is not necessarily resale-only: other new-construction homes may have longer reported market times.
Are the ZIP codes moving together?
Direct Answer: No. In October 2026, the median sold price rose in 32259 to $607,500 from $559,000, while 32081 was nearly flat at $685,000 versus $690,000.
What it means: Even neighboring ZIP codes can have different sales mixes. A seller in 32081 should not use the 32259 median change as a shortcut for pricing.
Within the St. Augustine section, October 2026 medians were $680,000 in 32080, $350,000 in 32084, $543,500 in 32092, and $540,000 in 32095. The range is a reminder that one combined median cannot price every property.
What if your home didn’t sell the first time?
Direct Answer: October 2026 single-family homes in St. Augustine and northern St. Johns County did sell, but the number of closings and reported market times differed by area and by how new-construction sales were recorded.
What it means: An expired or withdrawn listing deserves a fresh look at its asking price, condition, photographs, competition, and the homes buyers chose instead.
Professional observation for Michelle Ortelli’s review: An unsuccessful listing calls for a fresh comparison with the homes buyers actually purchased, followed by a review of price and presentation. The October numbers are a starting point, not a substitute for that property-specific review.
Seller takeaway
If you own a single-family home in St. Augustine or northern St. Johns County, the higher October medians may be encouraging. But pricing should reflect your own ZIP code, neighborhood, condition and competing listings. In particular, do not use a builder’s closing-entry CDOM as a promise of how quickly an existing home will sell.
Buyer takeaway
If you’re shopping for a single-family home in these areas, the median-price increases do not mean every home is becoming more expensive at the same rate. Compare individual properties and look at final list-price relationships, home condition and the available alternatives.
Bottom line
October 2026 brought higher median closing prices in both St. Augustine and northern St. Johns County, with different sales-volume patterns. Market times also shortened, even after setting aside identified closing-entry new-construction transactions. For homeowners planning to sell or relist, the best next step is a property-level comparison rather than relying on the regional median alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is October’s data a good reason to relist my St. Augustine single-family home now?
St. Augustine recorded 192 single-family closings in October 2026 versus 193 a year earlier, so sales continued at nearly the same pace. Whether to relist now depends on your home’s condition, asking price and current competition.
Are buyers getting more negotiating room in northern St. Johns County?
In 32259 and 32081, sellers received an average 98.7% of final list price in October 2026 versus 97.5% in October 2025. That does not point to more negotiating room across the entire closed-sale group, although individual properties may differ.
Should I wait because St. Augustine home prices may rise again?
The October 2026 St. Augustine median was $540,000 versus $510,000 a year earlier, but those are two different groups of sold homes. The data alone cannot establish what your individual home will be worth after waiting.
What mistake should an owner avoid after a northern St. Johns County listing expires?
Do not assume the 39-day October 2026 median CDOM in 32259 and 32081 applies to every resale. The comparison excluding identified closing-entry new-construction homes was 57 days, and your listing deserves its own competitive review.
Which St. Augustine ZIP code had the most single-family closings in October 2026?
Among the four ZIP codes covered, 32092 recorded 102 single-family closings in October 2026. That makes it the largest contributor to this St. Augustine grouping, so its mix of properties influences the combined figures.
Sources
Flexmls individual closed-sale exports, October 2025 and October 2026; single-family residence records for ZIP codes 32080, 32084, 32092, 32095, 32259 and 32081.
NEFAR/realMLS October 2026 county dashboard supplied separately; not used as ZIP-specific evidence.
Identified 0–1-day new-construction closing entries are shown separately.
About the Author
Michelle Ortelli, licensed since 2006, serves Northeast Florida with The Ortelli Team at Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty. Her specialties include luxury residential homes, relocation, second homes, first-time buyers and helping homeowners whose homes did not sell the first time.
Michelle Ortelli |
Trusted Real Estate Advisor in Northeast Florida | Specializing in
Helping Homeowners in St. Augustine | St. Johns County | Northeast Florida Sell
with Confidence | Global Luxury | Residential | Relocation | Second Homes |
Expired Listings
904-570-8130 | mortelli@cbvfl.com | www.ortelliteam.com