What should St. Augustine, Florida, homeowners change before relisting an expired single-family home?
Start by reviewing your asking price, property condition, marketing presentation, showing access, and buyer feedback. Compare your home with recent comparable sales and the properties buyers can choose from today. Look for patterns in the feedback before deciding what to change.
Should you stay with your agent or change your strategy?
If your listing expired, ask your agent what they learned from the first listing and what they would do differently. A revised plan should explain how they arrived at the price, how they would present the home, and how they would make it easier for buyers to see it. If you’re considering another agent, use those same questions to compare their approach.
I’m Michelle Ortelli, REALTOR® with The Ortelli Team at Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty. I offer this free, eight-question assessment to help St. Augustine homeowners review their previous listing and decide what to discuss before putting their home back on the market.
Take the Stay or Switch Assessment
For local market context, read my October 2026 St. Augustine and Northern St. Johns County Single-Family Home Market Update.
Want to talk through what happened with your listing? Contact me for a personalized listing review.
Michelle Ortelli, REALTOR® | The Ortelli Team | Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty
904-570-8130 | mortelli@cbvfl.com | www.ortelliteam.com | Florida license SL3313720